Federal Court Matters

Home  ›  Practice  ›  Federal Court Matters

A refusal letter rarely explains itself. It gives you a conclusion, a section number, and nothing you can work with. The reasoning sits in the officer’s notes, which you have not seen, and the deadline to do anything about it is already running.

Kayani Law Firm acts on applications for leave and judicial review in the Federal Court of Canada, and on appeals to the Federal Court of Appeal. Guided by Principal Counsel Junaid Kayani, with over 40 years of practice in Ontario, together with Partner Birinderpal Singh Brar, we act for individuals, permanent residents and applicants whose immigration or citizenship decisions need to be challenged.

We act in English, Urdu, Hindi, Punjabi, and Farsi, so you can go through the decision you have received and the options open to you in the language you are most comfortable with.

Federal Court Legal Services We Handle

Proceedings in the Federal Court run on the Federal Courts Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. F-7, the Federal Courts Rules, SOR/98-106, and for immigration matters the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, S.C. 2001, c. 27 together with the Federal Courts Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection Rules.

Whether the matter is a refused visa, a delayed application that has gone unanswered for years, or a removal date that has been set, the same thing decides it at the outset: the deadline. Miss the filing period or fail to meet the leave requirement and the merits never get looked at.

We act at every stage — the leave application, the supporting affidavits, the application record, and oral advocacy at the judicial review hearing. Most of what reaches us began as an immigration decision, and our immigration team handles applications, appeals and responses to procedural fairness letters at the IRCC stage, before a refusal ever reaches the Court.

Core Practice Areas Handled by Our Federal Court Team

Judicial review of federal decisions

Where a federal officer, board or tribunal has made a decision that appears unreasonable, or reached it through an unfair process, the remedy is usually an application for judicial review in the Federal Court.

It is worth being precise about what the Court does, because this is where expectations and reality diverge most sharply. The Court does not decide your application. It examines whether the decision-maker’s decision was justified, transparent and intelligible on the record that was in front of them. If the application succeeds, the decision is set aside and the matter goes back to a different decision-maker for a fresh decision. You get another decision, not the outcome you wanted. Sometimes the fresh decision is another refusal.

The same process applies to decisions of federal boards, tribunals and commissions outside the immigration context, where no statutory right of appeal exists.

Immigration refusals and appeals

Most matters reaching the Federal Court arrive as refusals — visa applications, permanent residence, sponsorship, citizenship.

Where a right of appeal exists, an appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division may be available first, and an IAD decision can itself be taken to the Federal Court on leave. Where the Federal Court has decided a matter and the judge has certified a question of general importance, an appeal to the Federal Court of Appeal may follow — without that certified question, there is no appeal.

Delayed applications

Some applicants are never refused. They are left waiting, well past published processing times, with no explanation and no one to ask.

Where a decision-maker has a duty to decide and has not done so within a reasonable period, an application for mandamus asks the Court to order IRCC to make a decision. It compels a decision, not a particular decision — the application can still be refused afterwards, and sometimes is. What it ends is the silence.

Removal and risk

Removal is one of the few immigration situations that runs on a genuine emergency timeline, and the thing most people assume is wrong: filing a judicial review does not stop a removal. Unless a statutory stay applies, the removal proceeds on its date regardless of the application sitting at the Court. Where a removal date has been set, an urgent motion for a stay of removal has to be brought.

Before removal, some individuals are eligible for a Pre-Removal Risk Assessment, which considers whether they would face persecution, torture or cruel and unusual treatment if returned. A refused assessment can be challenged on judicial review.

Separately, an application on humanitarian and compassionate grounds under section 25 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act asks the Minister to exercise discretion in light of a person’s circumstances, including their establishment in Canada and the best interests of any child affected.

Why Choose Kayani Law Firm for a Federal Court Matter

  • Rights of Audience in the Federal Court — We are licensed by the Law Society of Ontario and can appear before the Federal Court of Canada. An immigration consultant cannot, which means a consultant who prepared your refused application has to hand the file to someone else at exactly the point it gets difficult.
  • The IRCC Stage and the Court Stage on One File — Our immigration team handles the application and any procedural fairness letter; the same firm takes it to the Court if it is refused. Nothing is re-explained to a new adviser against a 15-day deadline.
  • Direct Access to Experienced Counsel — Principal Counsel Junaid Kayani with Partner Birinderpal Singh Brar.
  • Five Languages — English, Urdu, Hindi, Punjabi, and Farsi, so you can read the officer’s reasons with us rather than through an interpreter.
  • Urgent Work — Stay of removal motions are brought on short notice and we act on them.
  • A Realistic Assessment First — Leave is refused in a great many applications and no reasons are given when it is. We will tell you what we think your prospects are before you commit to the process.
  • Transparent Retainer Terms — Scope and retainer agreed in writing before work begins.

What to Bring to Your Initial Consultation

One document matters more than all the others, and one date matters more than all the documents.

  • The decision itself — the refusal letter, the tribunal decision, or the removal direction.
  • The date you received it. Not the date on the letter: the date it reached you. The filing deadline runs from notice, and if there is any doubt bring the envelope or the email.
  • The application that was refused, with everything you submitted in support of it.
  • The officer’s notes, if you already have them.
  • Any previous application to Canada or elsewhere, including ones refused or withdrawn.
  • If a removal date has been set, the direction to report and the date.
  • Your passport and your current status documents.

What to Expect in a Federal Court Application

Applications follow a set sequence, and the early deadlines are short. Knowing the stages helps in deciding whether to proceed, and in understanding where the work actually sits.

1. Filing the application for leave

Within 15 days of being notified of a decision made inside Canada, or 60 days for one made outside. The initial filing is brief; it starts the proceeding and preserves the deadline. An extension can be requested, but it has to be justified, and intending to apply is not the same as having applied.

2. Obtaining the reasons

Once the application is filed, the Court registry requests the decision-maker’s reasons and the material that was before them. In immigration matters this usually includes the officer’s notes, and the notes frequently contain reasoning that appears nowhere in the refusal letter. This is often the first time anyone on your side learns why the application actually failed.

3. The applicant’s record

The substantive written argument, supported by affidavit evidence. Rule 10 sets 30 days for this, though the Court extended the perfection period in May 2025 by a further 45 days for unperfected applications, a measure that can be varied, so the operative date should be confirmed on your file rather than assumed. This stage is where the case is made and it is the most demanding part of the process.

4. The respondent’s memorandum, and any reply

The Minister files a written argument within 30 days of the applicant’s record. The applicant may reply within 10 days of that.

5. The leave decision

A judge decides on the written material alone whether the case is arguable enough to go forward. There is no hearing. No reasons are given if leave is refused, and the refusal cannot be appealed — which is the hardest feature of this process to explain to a client, because it means an application can end without anyone ever telling you why.

6. The hearing

If leave is granted, an oral hearing is scheduled. If the application succeeds, the decision is set aside and the matter returns to a different decision-maker for a fresh decision.

Reapply, or Challenge the Decision?

This is the real question, and the answer usually turns on something you do not have yet: the officer’s reasons.

There is a structural point behind it. Judicial review is confined to the record that was before the original decision-maker. Fresh evidence is generally not admissible, with narrow exceptions such as establishing procedural unfairness or providing background. So if the application failed because the evidence was thin, judicial review cannot fix it — the Court will be looking at the same thin record. That case needs a better application, not a review.

Judicial review is for a different problem: where the officer misapplied the law, ignored evidence that was in front of them, or the process was unfair. Those are errors in the decision, not gaps in the evidence.

Reading the reasons is what tells you which one you have. And the 15 and 60-day clocks run from notice of the decision, not from when the reasons arrive — so if judicial review is a possibility at all, the file needs opening immediately, with the reasons requested in parallel.

Where Federal Court Work Connects to the Rest of the Firm

Almost every Federal Court file here begins as an immigration decision. Our immigration team prepares the applications, responds to procedural fairness letters, and advises on inadmissibility — and where a refusal cannot be resolved at the IRCC stage, the same firm takes it to the Court.

Where a person’s status is affected by a proceeding in the Ontario courts, our civil litigation team works alongside. Where a separation affects a sponsorship undertaking, our family law team deals with that side.